Does cell phone use increase the risk for brain cancer? Discussion of safety, danger and cautions
Using a cell phone for more than a decade can increase
the risk of some brain cancers. Dr. Lennart Hardell of University Hospital in Orebro, Sweden and
colleagues reviewed data from prior studies and now believe that cell phone use
can cause brain cancer, with the greatest risk seen on the side of the head where the
mobile phone is held. The types of brain cancer that they noticed were
acoustic neuromas and gliomas.
Acoustic neuromas are benign growths on the nerve linking the ear to the brain,
while gliomas are malignant tumors of the brain and nervous
system.
Dr. Lennart Hardell and his group identified 18 studies of brain tumor risk among long-term
cell phone users, 11 of which provided data for 10 years or longer. When the
findings were analyzed collectively, the researchers found people who used cell
phones for at least a decade had atwo fold greater risk of acoustic neuromas and gliomas. Occupational Environmental Medicine, September 2007.
Comments: Since the use of cell phones is almost unavoidable in our
modern society, users may wish to minimize the time they talk on a cell phone.
Perhaps changing sides could help reduce the exposure to the same part of the
brain?
Mechanism of cancer formation
Cell phones could boost brain tumor risk by exposing the brain to
electromagnetic energy. Research in the past was not long enough to determine
cause and effect relationship, but an evaluation of more than a decade of
research is making it more likely that there is a relationship.
Acoustic neuroma association
Cell phone use and acoustic neuroma: the need for standardized questionnaires
and access to industry data.
Surg Neurol. 2009 Sep; Han YY, Kano H, Davis DL, Niranjan A, Lunsford LD.
Center for Environmental Oncology-University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute (UPCI),
Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA.
The capacity of radiofrequency from cell phones to be absorbed into the brain
has prompted concerns that regular cell phone use may increase the risk of
acoustic neuroma (AN) and other brain tumors. This article critically evaluates
current literature on cell phone use and AN risks and proposes additional
studies to clarify any possible linkage. Through a PubMed search, we identified
and reviewed 10 case-control studies and 1 cohort study of AN risks associated
with cell phone use and a meta-analysis of long-term mobile phone use and its
association with AN and other brain tumors. Most studies did not find
association between the development of AN and cell phone use, but some studies
that followed cases for 10 years or more did show an association. Cell phone use
was not associated with increased risk for AN in the Danish cohort study, which
excluded business users from their study. The meta-analysis, which included 3
case-control studies, found that subjects who used cell phones for at least 10
years had a 2.4-fold greater risk of developing ipsilateral AN. In general,
retrospective studies are limited in the ability to assess cell phone exposure
because of recall bias and misclassification. The evaluation of AN risk factors
is challenging due to its long latency. Some studies of longer term cell phone
use have found an increased risk of ipsilateral acoustic neuroma. Adopting a
prospective approach to acquire data on cell phone use, obtaining retrospective
billing records that provide independent evaluations of exposures, and
incorporating information on other key potential risk factors from
questionnaires could markedly advance the capacity of studies to evaluate the
impact of cell phones on acoustic neuroma.
Distribution of cell phone radio
frequencies in human brain
Distribution of RF energy emitted by mobile phones in anatomical
structures of the brain.
Phys Med Biol. 2008 June. Radiation Group, International Agency for Research
on Cancer, 150 cours Albert Thomas, Lyon 69372, France.
The rapid worldwide increase in mobile phone use in the last decade has
generated considerable interest in possible cell phone brain cancer causing
effects of radio frequency. Because exposure to radio frequency from phones is
localized, if a risk exists it is likely to be greatest for tumors in regions
with greatest energy absorption. The objective of the current paper was to
characterize the spatial distribution of RF energy in the brain, using results
of measurements made in two laboratories on 110 phones used in Europe or Japan.
Most (97-99% depending on frequency) appears to be absorbed in the brain
hemisphere on the side where the phone is used, mainly (50-60%) in the temporal
lobe. The average relative SAR is highest in the temporal lobe (6-15%, depending
on frequency, of the spatial peak SAR in the most exposed region of the brain)
and the cerebellum (2-10%) and decreases very rapidly with increasing depth,
particularly at higher frequencies. The SAR distribution appears to be fairly
similar across cell phone models, between older and newer phones and between
phones with different antenna types and positions.
Questions
Are there any herbal
products that could reduce the risk for any potential damage from cell phone
use?
We are not sure at this time.
Would the use of an anti cancer agent such as
AHCC reduce the risk for brain cancer?
We are not aware of such studies.